Freedom Force International

The Issues

WHY DO YOU OPPOSE GOVERNMENT HEALTH CARE?
Analysis © 2009 by G. Edward Griffin
Published 2009 September 22.

On September 19, 2009, I received the following email from a subscriber to Unfiltered News who wished to remain anonymous:

I am English and only moved to the USA three years ago when I married my wife who is American. I have huge respect for you Mr Griffin. I read your book 'World without Cancer' in the 1970's - the same period you say you visited my country, the UK, and evaluated its' health service. Your book on Cancer was well researched and well written, and I am sure it broke the fixed thinking of many people about the correctness of mainstream cancer medicine.

I am very sorry therefore to disagree with you about the US health service being superior to the UK's health service. Here are some facts about the UK's national health service:

• Everyone is covered, be they employed or not. • Everyone has the right still to take out Private Health Insurance or get cover under their company health insurance plan - about 10% of the population do. The private health service does offer a greater level of care and faster service. • Everyone employed in the UK pays a National Health contribution taken from their payroll. • The cost per head of population for UK health care is about half that of US health care and yet everyone is covered. • Some hospitals are old, but old hospitals are now a rarity. • You cannot loose your home or go bankrupt if a family member gets ill. • No one finds themselves uninsured or exempted from cover because of their age or illness record. • General Practitioners form the backbone of the UK health service, they keep their responsibility of care for you as a patient no matter who or where you are referred to with a specific illness. • It goes without saying that people in the UK do not fear the cost of illness. • The most you can pay for a prescription is $16, If you are over 60 or unemployed or chronically ill the cost is zero.

Here in the USA my wife has unfortunately been ill on a number of occasions these last three years, so I have experienced the so called 'health industry' here and I have been horrified at the US medical systems treatment of uninsured sick people. I have met many doctors, only two of whom I have any respect for as humanists. The rest appear to have become doctors for the wealth and/or social prestige doctors can expect. In truth I have found the majority of the American Health Establishment a mercenary group of avaristic hypocrites.

In the USA 56% of the country's wealth is owned by 1% of the population. You can be sure those people and their families will get the very best health care money can buy. You can also be sure that whist a worker is working it pays to keep him or her and their family as healthy as possible with a company insurance program that pays a lot of the cost of health cover, (but may still not be enough to stop them loosing their home or going bankrupt.) You can also be sure that those beyond work in terms of age or illness will be discarded on the uninsured slag heap currently filled with 40 million other fellow Americans. I would have thought you could see all this, Mr Griffin.

This was my reply:

My opposition to government health care has nothing to do with admiration for the present monopolized system in the U.S. I am convinced that the quality and availability of health care must always decline under political control; I have witnessed that costs for basic services always increase under government regulations (although invisibly passed on to the taxpayer); and I know that government health care is an economic funnel into pharmaceutical companies (non-drug therapies are almost totally excluded). Even if none of that were true, however, I would still be opposed to politicized health care because of my concern for freedom. What the state pays for, it will control. When the state pays for our health care, our home mortgages and rent, our retirement, our unemployment benefits, our education, our job training, our food, the building of our automobiles, the liquidity of our banks, and all the other important aspects of our lives, the state will totally control every one of us. I am not fond of becoming a serf. I hope that Anonymous will step back and see the larger picture.

Printer Friendly

Back